I finally bit the bullet and decided to have the softtop replaced. I ordered the top on Autotopsdirect.com, per the recommendation of a local installer.

While i like the larger visibility of the plastic rear window, but I opted for the glass window because then I never have to worry about the window creasing, fogging, or cracking again.

The package arrived in great shape, and the top was very nicely packed. The glass has a protective film over it, and the material looks fantastic. It will be nice to finally have a top that doesnt have leaks and is in pristine condition.